It’s hard to mess up a dill mustard; the two are simply two flavors that work. Even a mediocre-to-serviceable dill mustard is still, usually, pretty good. That said, below is our definitive list of the best dill mustard varieties, listed alphabetically.

Braswell’s - Two mustards from Braswell’s claim spots on this list: their dill pickle mustard and their champagne dill mustard.

Dietz & Watson - A deli staple brand, but one that shouldn’t be overlooked among the lower-priced options, Dietz & Watson’s champagne dill mustard is well balanced and subtler than many deli varieties.

Inglehoffer - Inglehoffer’s creamy dill mustard is a great mid-priced option, and is especially delicious in deviled egg and chicken/tuna/potato salad recipes.

Paradigm Foodworks - Small-batch crafted in Oregon, Paradigm Foodworks garlic dill mustard is tangy, a little spicy and slightly sweet.

Sleeping Bear Farms - Sleeping Bear’s dill honey mustard is well-balanced and smooth, with no added sugar beyond Michigan Star Thistle honey.

Terrapin Ridge - Terrapin Ridge’s dill pickle mustard is a delicious blend of dill and Dijon, and is another that makes a good addition to deviled eggs and salads.

Trader Joe’s - Fancy? Not really. But Trader Joe’s dill pickle mustard is no slouch, with bold flavors that will stand up well to fish and meats.

Last updated, January 2023.